They're Real! Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara

Not the same - transfers to undereye

I rarely leave reviews but I'm so disappointed. This has been my go to mascara for at least the past 8 years and in the past year I've noticed transfer to my under eyes. Did a quick google and apparently it's not just me - dozens of reviews now noting the same. Don't know why they ruined a good thing but can no longer recommend!

Makes my eyelashes so long without even curling

Everyone keeps asking me if I’m wearing false eyelashes even got told that my eyelashes look so pretty it’s distracting the only reason I didn’t put 5 stars is because the mascara does run after a few hours and I look like a raccoon.

Cutest mascara I’ve used

This is probably the cutest mascara I’ve ever used and I did use a lash curler but with this ahhhhh I love it!

Changed the formula. Do not buy.

Came here for the same reason I see most reviewers saying. They changed the formula. It’s awful. Raccoon eyes after an hour. This is no more than a cheap drug store mascara. DO NOT waste your money.

I absolutely love this mascara. I only like lengthening ones, and this is so perfect. it has never clumped on me and looks so perfect and natural. the minis last me a while and don't really dry out. I don't plan on getting the full size because I'm scared it'll dry out before I use all of it and the minis last a while. overall, it's my number one mascara, and I can't wait to get another one.

A mess

Glad I bought the sample. It smears and smudges leaving most of the mascara under your eyes.

Changed the Formula

This used to be my go-to mascara for years. Now it causes major black circles under the eyes. I came here and read the other reviews and realized it’s not just me, looks like they changed the formula for the worse. Bummer.

What Happened?

This was my number one for the past 3 years and I’d give it 5 stars….But the last 2 times I’ve purchased, my lashes are clumpy and look short and stubby. I thought maybe I just bought “one” bad one, so I threw it away and bought 2 more. They’ve all been the same. Pls go back to the old formula!!!!!

It’s meh

Not impressive. Any L’Oréal or Rommel mascara will do you better.

Really like the wand with the nub tip to help declump. My only complaint is that it will smudge under my eyes by the end of the day. I don’t have that problem with any other mascara ever.

Don’t buy this product!

Don’t buy this product thinking you you’re getting the same product you grew to love! The formula has changed and cause raccoon eyes, is not long lasting lasting

Meh.

This product gives me racoon eyes. I apply it before work, and I notice by mid shift I need to wipe off parts of my under eye. I'm a bartender so I know I have a physical, active job but this mascara doesn't stand up to my other favorites. It is also hard to wash off. There's always crumbs and streaks left behind even after I use make up remover and face cleanser. The only reason I gave 2 stars is because if I've done a really smokey eye, the racoon eyes kinda blend in and you don't notice as much. I can't return it because I got it with a mascara sample pack coupon from years ago- but I would return it.